DEBATE 2 "Uniforms at school" (Terceros y Cuartos Medios)

The question of whether children should wear a uniform to school always makes for a lively debate, and not only among students! In some countries school uniform is normal and most schools make their students wear one.

Britain is the most obvious example of this, but in many other countries with strong links to Britain uniform often has to be worn to school - examples include Australia, Ireland, New Zealand, Singapore, Hong Kong, South Africa and many other African countries. Uniform is also required at almost all schools in Japan.

In other countries, particularly in continental Europe, the USA and Canada, uniform is very rare in state-funded schools, although private schools may have one.

Debates about school uniform have been going on for decades in different countries and districts, but during the 1990s state schools in the USA began to adopt uniforms.

At first uniform rules were seen as a way of stopping children dressing in gang colours in troubled urban areas. Later, claims that introducing uniform leads to better discipline and educational results encouraged other school districts and schools to make a change. Both the Clinton and Bush administrations have been in favour of school uniforms. Other countries have picked up on this trend - for example, there has been talk of making German children wear uniforms.

This topic looks at a very large number of arguments about uniforms. Not all of these will apply in every country or school, so take care only to select the ones that are relevant to debate. The proposition (affirmative or government) side here is arguing for uniforms to be scrapped, but the case could easily be reversed if your debate is about introducing uniforms instead.

What do you think about the obligation of wearing uniform at the most of schools in Chile? Do you have an opinion about that? Agree or disagree?




This is an example of how, in other countries, sees and feel the issue of wearing uniforms at school. (note: this is just an example, a point of view, anything else)

After reading the text post an specific opinion based only in one point of agreement or disagreement.

DEADLINE: Wednesday, July 8th, 2007.

30 comments:

Teacher Michael Rossel said...

Hello lads!
This week the debate will have something different.
You can write your real personal opinion, but...
the mark will be give to those who respond one of the posts writen by another schoolmate showing your agreement or disagreement.
so, first, write your opinion, and then, wait to respond to other opinion or point of view.
Good luck.
Read you soon!

Andres Opazo said...

I think that use uniforms at the school is not very comfortable .
My opinion is that is better don`t use uniforms because maybe the studens feel better when they wear the clothes that they want to express his "(gustos)".

Anonymous said...

I like to wear uniforms for the school... because it looks more formal...
I think that if everyone wear urban clothes in the school, we would provoke socio-economical differences 'Couse sometimes our parents don't have enough money to buy clothes
(jeans,vest,t-shirt,etc)
and...i'm sure,if we wear urban clothes, we'll ask to our mothers to buy us more clothes and it make a waste of money...

Carolina Muñoz 3ºF

Eduardo Gonzalez 4"A" said...

Eduardo Gonzalez Ibañez 4 "A"

About this theme, I think that the school uniforms are necessary ,because this show the school identity to the other people, besides the uniform represent the institution and the student is a part of this institution,in any other formal institution is necessary wear the correct clothe, besides the school uniform is very good for me (in my personal point of view)
About the opinion of Andres Opazo, I am disagree with him , because the students in the school do not have to show or expresarce thus the indentity , The students must study for the future of themselves ,nothing more.

Francisco Abarca said...

Francisco Abarca 4to B

I'm not sure quite agree in the use of uniform school.
I think that the use of uniformis a oppression abaout the academic freedom...for the point economic..is more cheap the clothes of street, ownig to that have buy uniform school year and years, but the clothes we can use for the school and the stroll around ... xD

.....

Sorry by the post .. is very short, but no hacve much time .. >_<
oks.
Bye.

francisco flores said...

Francisco Flores 4�A the original!


I agree with Eduardo: the uniforms represent intitucion to which we belong. in my opinion the uniforms serve to demonstrate equality between our classmate
and in certain point I agree with the Andres Opazo: we must be expressed, but for that they are them �jean day�. thanks xD!

Alfonso Pinto 3º-F said...

I think that the use of the uniform represent a institution ,but not is confortable, so, we would use urban-clothes , simply by its confort.

Anonymous said...

Constanza Flores, 3rd. F

I think about wearing uniforms at schools is correct because it makes to identify us like students and schools where us belong, also we look more formal and the most important it's doesn't make socio-economical differences,
because if all the students wearing urban clothes would cause discrimination between the rich person (who can buy new clothes, change it and show it everyday) and the poor person that can't buy it because it doesn't have sufficient money. So it is a good way of not producing socio-economical differences and discrimination between us, the students.

Anonymous said...

I agree that the students should wear uniforms at school because it's a way to distinguish one school from another, and the students are more in order.
Also, the use of other clothes provoke problems in the family, due to that somepeople don't have enough recourse to buy clothes and the children ask more and more clothes because their schoolmates have more than them, besides the social differences appear between the students!
Another reason is that when the students wear uniforms, they can identify with more facility who are the students of their own school, and to avoid that other students of other schools come in.

Evelyn Robles
3ºF

:D

Anonymous said...

I don't agree with to wear uniforms
because, this not show the marks or
the behavior inside of the classes, because if they wants do desorden or don't study for taking good marks,they will do with or without uniforms.

Jerzy Quintana Gonz�lez
4�B

Anonymous said...

I feel that is necesary the use of the uniform, because the use of the urban-clothes in the school identify a status social and besides generates the discrimination.

written by: Ivan ¨Mr.smile¨ Zabala 3º-F

Anonymous said...

well, first I have to apologize with the other post, because I didn't know how post you, so... I'm sorry =).

and with this, my truely opinion is that I agree with the uniform, because thank this are less discrimination social-economical difference, and to are less discrimination about the urban tribes, and the hate to feel each other, well, this don't stop the hate of their, but it diminishes a lot...
so that's all...
thank teacher

Lorena Sánchez 3roF

Anonymous said...

aaa... I disagree with andres opazo, because if we think in our confortabilities of the uniforms is obviously that we don't feel confortable, but if we think in our neighbor and the situation of their live, we are goin to see from another point... the point of the discrimination social-economical difference.

Lorena Sánchez 3roF

Anonymous said...

Carla Sánchez B. 4to "E"

Personally, I do not agree with the fact of wearing uniform at school day after day. Actually, I'd rather to wear the clothes that seems more comfortable to me. Besides, all this "uniform thing" won't make us better at any way.
I desagree with Eduardo González, about what he said: Uniform represents the institution.
I believe that the school can be recognized by other things more important than just an uniform.

PD:I, We, the students... are so used to wear uniform, that even when we hate it, we don't say a word.

Anonymous said...

mm...
I desagree with Anfres Opazo =$
because we can't think jusi in our confortibility... Because some partner of us could be happening an economic trouble...
although, the essential point of wear uniforms for the school, is for No discrimination!!

we should have to think in the rest!

:D

Carolina Muñoz
3ºF zD

Rodrigo Calle said...

I disagree with Carla Sanchez, because the uniform school represent the identity of a institution and show the discipline and organization inside the school.
I disagree with Andrés Opazo, because all don't feel like discomforts with the uniform, for example i like use the uniform school. If we search the comodity of all student never we will agree ourselves for this the comodity isn´t a valid argument.
Also the uniform school help to the students most pour because they can use the same uniform all week, but with the street clothes we should to change every day of clothes.
And finally in the school we must study and not to shine our clothes.
Thank you.

Anonymous said...

I disagree with Andres Opazo...
because we can't think just in our confortibility to express ourself... Because some partner of us could be happening an economic problem...
Also, the essential and most important about wearing uniforms at the school, is for No make Discrimination to our partners.

Thanks Teacher.


Constanza Flores Rojas, 3rd. F

Dánica said...

I disagree with francisco flores, I think that we dont NEED to wear uniforms because anybody wear the uniforms in the perfect rule.
So many students wear colured sweaters, or how they use their ties...

Dánica Mera 4 "E"

Anonymous said...

In my opinion, I agree with wear uniforms at schools of Chile, because for me is comfortable in the moment of to choose the clothes that I will use next day.
And wear it is more easy of to identify of other schools.

Melba Challapa Ch. 3ºE.

mauricio Vasquez 4to E said...

i think that we should wear uniform, because its represent our institution, this way , í'm not agree with andrés opazo because we're gonna study to the school and not express our "(GUSTOS)".

Anonymous said...

first that nothing the scholastic uniform is, very feasible and good since this it does not make them distinguish in the scholastic community reason why with the uniform “all we are equal” before the eyes of the others, clear with the uniform an social-economic discrimination does not exist so that becides to be easy to obtain it for the parents economically, there are no fights between the different social classes or groups fashion. .for to finish
the scholastic uniform is good so that he is feacible and sustainable in spite of all

CAROLINA SOZA 3ºE =)
sorry for delay ..for it was much

Anonymous said...

Well I was read the old post.

I disagree with Fco. Abarca, because the fact to buy year and year or days , clothes of street, that is more expensive. Moreover the uniform for school can to wear well and can to last more than one year.
Somepeople have it like memories of their adolescence.

by Melba Challapa 3E....a little late xp.

Anonymous said...

maaybe the uniforms not be the better uniforms dof arica , but is the representation or the higth school. and (nos)distinguish of other school.

Anonymous said...

the coment is of julieth lazcano 3ºe =)
a

Anonymous said...

i belive that isnt very necvesary because if ane waer uniform or not is similar because the uniform dont help in the shcool and dont do be most inteligent
scott escobar 3ºa

Anonymous said...

i disagree with mauricio velasquez because the important is be teach dont represent the school this dont help us for to be professionals in the future and dont be bad express the thant we feel
scott escobar 3ºa

Anonymous said...

in my ponion I am disagreement with the uniform uses in the school for you but orderly, we don't spend this way silver in another type of clothes, also that with the uniform we identify ourselves of school we plows, this way when other people don't eats they don't classify them bad

ayleen villca 3°e

Anonymous said...

.I am agree with the opinion of anders opazo that one you better sintiria to go with the uniform that but it doesn't adapt us for that we would feel but I eat two.

ayleen villca 3°e

Anonymous said...

I disagree with Francisco abarca because the uniforms are cheaper than the street clothes. Only the shoes are expensive and also are used it with the street clothes.
Besides, you need buy the uniforms once in all the year, on the oder hand, you can't use the same street clothes everyday. You need buy different clothes for everyday, you spend more money buying the street clothes that buying the uniform.

Evelyn Robles
3ºF

Anonymous said...

i think that school uniforms are to be worn at school seeing that it raises a level of security?safety. discipline will arise and people of different races and background will feel welcome.