DABATE: GOVERNMENT'S SECRETS vs PEOPLE INFORMED


After watching the movie CONTACT. The class was separated in two groups that are going to debate about a topic:

"THE GOVERNMENT SHOULD HIDE INFORMATION TO THE PEOPLE"


GROUP A is against the statement.
GROUP B is for the statement.

You should write your opinion according to the position - group - you are.

Your opinions will be evaluated and you will have to perform them in a real dabate returning from winter vacations.

18 comments:

Anonymous said...

Name:Cristian Burgos
Grade: 3ºD

*Questions:

4)How does the first visit from dr. traveylan russian patient end?
R= After dr. Travelyan go to storeroom, the old man wasn't there.

5)What explanation does he give?
R= He explains, when saw your father come out of your consult room , he thought that the examination was over.

6)How does blessington killed?
R= The russians (your enemyes), to enter blessington house they entered to bedroom blessington and they tied blessington and after they hanged blessington.

7)what is the reason for the murder?
R=Blessington(that is sutton), stealed the bank together with Biddle, Hayward and Cartwrigh.They stealed 7.000 pounds but, blessington decided to help the police.They all go to the jail for 15 years, after they decided take revenge.

8)Where did the money that helped dr. Traveylan really come from?
R=Came from steal the bank. :D

Anonymous said...

Name: Katherine Castillo
Grade: 3ºmedio C

4-.How does the first visit from the Trevelyan's Russian patient end?
After the doctor goes for medicine in the storeroom when the russian patient was in state of catalepsy. He come back and the patient was not there.

5-.What explanation does he give?
The Russian came later, and he said when his catalepsy goes away he don't remember anything and he didn't know when he was so he walked out the room.

6-.How is Blessington killed?
The murderers into the Mr. Blessington's room, they tied him to prevent him from crying out. They hanged him and thy left.

7-.What is the reason for the murder?
Was a revenge, because Biddle and Hayward goes to prision because Blessington betrayed them and help the police sent to bouth in prision for fifteen years and Blessington was free with all the money.

8-.Where did the money that helped Dr. Traveylan really come from?
Come from the Worthingdon Bank robbery, because Blessington was part of the robbers.


...

†Šнιžυε-Šαи† said...

Teacher, Can ignore the nick? xD

Name: Gabriela Huarachi
Grade: 3ºC

4)How does the first visit from dr. traveylan russian patient end?

After the doctor travelyan checks the Russian patient, he is going to look for a medicine to the storeroom and when I return Travelyan, the patient had gone away.

5)What explanation does he give?
The patient Russian explains to travelyan that he had an attack of catalepsy and when he recovered had forgotten where he was and left of the "strange" room

6)How does blessington killed?
ex-companions of Blessington had entered to the bedroom's Blessington where they tied of the neck and hanged, Apparently making this a suicide.

7)what is the reason for the murder?
Blessington, where his true name was Sutton, with his companions, Biddle, Cartwright and Hayward, they had stolen the Worthingdon bank, Sutton and betrayed to his friends and betrays with the police suffer fifteen years in jail

8)Where did the money that helped dr. Traveylan really come from?
The money comes from Worthingon bank that they, Sutton and ex-friendo stole in the Past.

Anonymous said...

Name: Isabela García
Grade: 3º A H.C.

4. How does the first visit from dr. Traveylan russian patient end?
The first visit ends when the Dr. Trevelyan goes to look for a medicine in his storeroom because the russian patient was in state of catalepsy. when the dr. returns the patient had disappeared.

5. What explanation does he give?
The russian patient says that he doesn't remember what had happened. When he woke up, he thought he was in a strange room, then he left the room.


6. How is blessington killed?
The murdered entered to the blessington's room and they hanged him. The police and the Dr. thought that blessington had hanged himself.

7. What is the reason for the murder?
Blessington had stealed a bank with Cartwright, Biddle and Hayward. Blessington had decided to help the police, then Cartwright was hanged and Biddle and Haywars were sent to prison. Now they Wanted vengeance.

8. Where did the money that helped Dr. Traveylan really come from?
The money came from Worthingdon Bank robbery that Blessington and his ex-friends had done.

Anonymous said...

hello teacher
disculpe por enviarle la tarea hoy es que no pude ir a un ciber antes

¿How does the first visit from Dr. Trevelyan Russian patient end?

R:When the Dr. Trevelyan looks for a medicine in his pantry because patient has catalepsy. When Trevelyan returns the patient was not .

¿What explanation does he give?
R:The said he had an attack of catalepsy and therefore can not remember anything and when he was awakened in a room unknown.

¿How is Blessington killed?
R:The murderers entered in the room of Blessington and the hanged.

¿What is the reason for the murder?
R:
Because Blessington deception to their fellow puting in prison.

¿Where did the money that helped Dr.Trevelyan really come from?
R:The money went of the theft of the bank Worthingdon.

Name: Jesenia Lázaro M.
Grade: 3°E H.C.

:p

Anonymous said...

Name:Eduardo Varas
Grade:3ªf

4.-¿how does the first visit from DR. traveleyan russian patient end?
A:DR decide go to look for a medicine to storeroom, the patient russian was not there.

5.-¿What explanation does he give?
A:he thought what the examination was over.

6.-¿How is Blessington killed?
A:first enter to house and after tied blessington and after they hanged blessington.

7.-¿What is the reason for the murder?
A:basicly because a traition of part of blessington to help to police

8.-¿Where did the money that helped Dr.Trevelyan really come from?
A:came from the robery of the bank


bye bye bye bye bye bye

Anonymous said...

comencemos el debate !!
"THE GOVERNMENT SHOULD HIDE INFORMATION TO THE PEOPLE"

Anonymous said...

Teacher, Sorry I couldn't post my answers before. I'll answer here in anyway.

4.) How does the first visit from Dr. Travelyan's Russian patient end?

R: The Russian Patient disappeared! while the Dr was to search the medicine to "save" him, when he arrived nobody was here! the Russian Patient has disappeared!

5.) What explanation does he give?

R: He said that when he has the attack of catalepsy, his mind was empty, without know where are himself! And the next day, he didn't remember what has happened.

6.)How is Blessington killed?

R: The Murders killed Blessington hanging him in the middle of the room, with a rope.

7.) What is the Reason of the murder?

R: He was who assault the Bank with his "friends", and he told at the Police-Men who were the attackers, he told the truth to save himself! And he didn't go to Prison. His "friends" promised him: we'll revenge!

8.) Where did the money that helped Dr. Travelyan really come from?

R: The money really come from the Bank Robbery...


Rubén Castillo O.
3º A H.C

Anonymous said...

I am in favour of "THE GOVERNMENT SHOULD HIDE INFORMATION TO THE PEOPLE"
Because in this way it prevents the collective paranoia and the control couldn’t loses itself.

By Isabela garcía Guillén
3ºA H.C.

Anonymous said...

I am in favour of "THE GOVERNMENT SHOULD HIDE INFORMATION TO THE PEOPLE"
Because for example in the movie “Contact” the government says that Ellie Arroway will travel through space, then a religious fanatical causes a terrorist attack, it did that all the spaceship exploits. But finally equal she travels.
This could be a scientific advance very important. But this terrorist attack could have been prevented.
By Isabela García Guillén
3º A H.C.

Anonymous said...

teacher I don`t understand
don´t see if this is for "cuarto", so ....that.


And other thing, finally I have the answers of the "Man with the Twisted Lip".

1. are Holmes and Watson at the bar of Gold? yes,a both, Holmes was hiding for researching a case, while Watson was searching to Mr Isa.
2. is Holmes surprised when Mrs. Saint receives a letter from her husband? Yes, Holmes jumped of the surprise.
3. does Mrs. Saint believe the letter is really from her husband?
yes, totally.
4. does Holmes take a cloth with him or his prision visit? Holmes brougth a cloth to Mr. Neville .
5. has Neville led a secret life?
yes, he was a begger in the streets of London.
6. how does Neville explain to his wife why he has been away rom home?
Mrs. Saint Clair sent a letter to his wife explaining that she don´t worry for him and that she has be pacient.
______________________________________

by Melba Challapa Ch.
4ºB HC

see you monday...
q lata

Anonymous said...

Group B is for the statement

i think that the government should hide information to the people because if all the secrets of government were revealed some persons can cause chaos because maybe they aren`t in agreement with the decisions of the government and for don`t to start disasters is better hide the information . Example of this was the man who wasn`t in agreement with the travel of the spaceship and he caused a explosion with a bomb and at the same time he caused the terror to the persons who were see that .This prove that the government should hide information especially the information that will cause disturbances in the society

by Mariana Lumio
4ºC

Daniel Meneses 3ºE said...

I'm a favour of the government should hide information to the people, because if the government makes public some important information, people could fall into panic, chaos and madness, is more safe hide the information and wait to tell to the people.


DANIEL MENESES
3ºE

Anonymous said...

Name: Katherine Castillo R.
Grade: 3ºmedio C


I'm against that the government should hide information to the people, because this information can mean the difference between life and death of thousands of people, futhermore the people of the goberment were chosen by all the people for they represents to them, that mean, the people give a confidence vote to the people in government, therefor, the government must be sincere with all people.

†Šнιžυε-Šαи† said...

Teacher, Can ignore the nick...

Name: Gabriela Huarachi
Grade: 3ºC

I am in against that the government should hide information to the people, because one of the principal reasons is that all in the world have right to thinking in agreement to certain aspects as the messages of "other" beings, also for that a small hidden information can causar that the life of thousands of persons who were foreign to the problem die. Besides that the citizens that chose to his "representatives" between them and the people finds out the information can lose the confidence in the government and representatives and this would cause the panic or revolutions.

Anonymous said...

Questions:
Diego Chandia
3ºB HC

4)How does the first visit from dr. traveylan russian patient end?
R= After dr. Travelyan go to storeroom, the old man wasn't there.

5)What explanation does he give?
R= He explains, when saw your father come out of your consult room , he thought that the examination was over.

6)How does blessington killed?
R= The russians (your enemyes), to enter blessington house they entered to bedroom blessington and they tied blessington and after they hanged blessington.

7)what is the reason for the murder?
R=Blessington(that is sutton), stealed the bank together with Biddle, Hayward and Cartwrigh.They stealed 7.000 pounds but, blessington decided to help the police.They all go to the jail for 15 years, after they decided take revenge.

8)Where did the money that helped dr. Traveylan really come from?
R=Came from steal the bank.

Anonymous said...

Name: Marcela Aliaga
Grade:3ºB
Name: Sergio Campusano
Grade:3ºC


How does the first visit from the Trevelyan's Russian patient end?
After the doctor goes for medicine in the storeroom when the russian patient was in state of catalepsy. He come back and the patient was not there.

5-.What explanation does he give?
The Russian came later, and he said when his catalepsy goes away he don't remember anything and he didn't know when he was so he walked out the room.

6-.How is Blessington killed?
The murderers into the Mr. Blessington's room, they tied him to prevent him from crying out. They hanged him and thy left.

7-.What is the reason for the murder?
Was a revenge, because Biddle and Hayward goes to prision because Blessington betrayed them and help the police sent to bouth in prision for fifteen years and Blessington was free with all the money.

8-.Where did the money that helped Dr. Traveylan really come from?
Come from the Worthingdon Bank robbery, because Blessington was part of the robbers.

Anonymous said...

Name: Marcela Aliaga
Grade:3ºB

I found that the government is concealing information to the people and by concealing information that the people could occur many misfortunes as the people do not have no idea what is happening in the country. Why the government has to withhold information to the People, where it is the people who gives them the confidence to elect them?. It is fair to give confidence to those who choose to represent the people? at the end when we finish concealing information. The government must tell all the people.